The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20111217082309/http://vimeo.com/4520463
00:00
258
At the DMCA 1201 hearings at the Copyright Office at the Library of Congress, representatives from the MPAA showed a video demonstrating how users can videorecord a TV set. They argue this is an acceptable analog alternative to breaking copy protection on a DVD.

The hearings occur every three years to determine whether the Librarian at the Library of Congress (through direction of the Copyright Office) should create exemptions to the anti-circumvention provisions in the Digital Millennium Copyright Act.

In 2006, film and media professors were granted an exemption in order to break copy protection on DVDs so that they could utilize high quality video clips in classroom teaching. Up for consideration during the 2009 exemption hearings is whether this exemption should be extended to apply to faculty teaching in all disciplines, and whether the exemption should apply to students.

Credits

Likes

See all likes
  • Wolf Peterson 3 years ago
    This is hilarious.

    So many mise-en-abîme.
  •  
  • Pascal Balthrop 3 years ago
    man, now that is old school bananas.
  •  
  • devin chalmers 3 years ago
    I remember in high school I was copying a bunch of clips off VHS for a school project. Had to grab em in little 2-second chunks (as long as it took for my DV camera to recognize the Macrovision) and then cut them back together in iMovie. (I had a lot more free time back then.)
  •  
  • Geoff Pedder 3 years ago
    stating the obvious here, but the mpaa are full retard.
    What happened to non-commercial fair use?
    also, don't they see the glaring irony in this?
  •  
  • Bryan Bortz 3 years ago
    Apart from how stupid this line of thinking is, why the hell did they use such an obnoxious and disturbing clip for the second one?
  • Klim Levene 3 years ago
    and they had to play it twice too. :)
  •  
  • Andy Brice 3 years ago
    Two things in this video stand out to me as particularly ridiculous.

    Even though the results of two different processes are identical, one process is legal but one is not; and they're defending this?

    In giving this demonstration showing how easy it is to circumvent, aren't the MPAA effectively proving DVD DRM achieves nothing?
  •  
  • Jeremy Schulz plus 3 years ago
    I'm sure the MPAA concedes that the same principle should apply to movie theater screens.
  • Klim Levene 3 years ago
    as long as a teacher does it... so pretty much yes. You can now legally torrent the cams.
  • Jayleen Sun 3 years ago
    This was funny... (next comment, below).
  •  
  • Alex King plus 3 years ago
    So amazingly brainless...
  •  
  • Lampstand Films 3 years ago
    Gruber and Siracusa are informed already, but i thought i'd tell you...

    at 1:15... you can see this demonstration video is being played to the court on VLC.

    your stunned silence means you are just as in awe as i am.
  •  
  • Jon 3 years ago
    So if you get caught using the "approved" method in the movie theater, you can just say, "I'm a teacher working on a lesson plan."

    PS Is it me or does the image in the RSS feed look as if the woman in the background has her left breast hanging out? (img9.imageshack.us/img9/8470/mpaa.jpg )
  • Jayleen Sun 3 years ago
    This comment made me LMAO!
  •  
  • andy kuepper 3 years ago
    OMg. How is it that the most technologically ignorant people are in charge of making laws regarding our technology. I'm not even sure of the point of all of this? Was it ever mentioned. I hope school children "studying" Harry Potter Movies (why?) enjoy craptastic quality. For me, I will be ripping the crap out of Macrovision, a technology based on DEGRADING legally purchased media, which ends up destroying what I pay for when I want to do something crazy like hook a VCR(?) or Dvd Player up to my video projector. These guys are all morons. I'm in the movie business myself, have had my OWN film pirated, and I don't care about the MPAA or "copy protecting" any of my media. It's a loss cause, and hurts more than it helps.
  •  
  • nick s 3 years ago
    not shown: the segment where they bring out a monk with a quill pen to copy a document.
  •  
  • Luke 3 years ago
    haha.
  •  
  • J.C. LaValley 3 years ago
    The MPAA -- like it's "trailblazing" cousin, the RIAA -- is so incredibly effed-up and stupid, it just never ceases to amaze me. Why not just have the teacher take a series of photographs of the TV screen -- at, like, 30 images per second -- and then, simply paste the photos into a blank book. The schoolkids could then have endless fun *simulating* watching the original -- by flipping the pages so fast, that the images would seem to blur together, creating the incredible illusion of a "moving picture"!
  • Jayleen Sun 3 years ago
    Lol!
  •  
  • Tanner Powell 3 years ago
    Wow. They really don't get it. That's pretty staggering. I keep thinking of Dr. Evil doing the Macarena.
  •  
  • Nilz plus 3 years ago
    Sort of a weird feedback thing going on with the recording of a recording of a recording.
  • Jayleen Sun 3 years ago
    :-)
  •  
  • rob friedman 3 years ago
    The guy should have said, "I won't go through the whole clip as I don't want to break any actual copyright laws."
  •  
  • Justin Lincoln plus 3 years ago
    Sad. Laugh, cry? Carry on?
  •  
  • Lampstand Films 3 years ago
    using VLC in court for this case is staggering. VLC was built so that people could play DVDs over the network using DeCSS - the *EXACT* software they're fighting against in this case.

    The only equivalence i can come up with that is closely comparable would be if they were a pro-speed camera group and one of their lawyers pulled into the courthouse parking lot at 95 mph, yanked a four-wheel drift into the driveway, and double parked in handicapped parking... all while being watched live on the courtroom floor via security camera.
  •  
  • uusibera 3 years ago
    This video shows the psychopathy of the people who run the entertainment business.

    Intellectual Property is only abstract ideas, thoughts, and stories; not real property. The intellect is used to create real physical property like gadgets: computers, telephones, music players, etc. or inventions like cars and airplanes. First you have to have an idea to create something real. If you want to call that idea intellectual property for that purpose seems reasonable. But never for something that always remains abstract.

    Intellectual Property in the sense used by the entertainment business is non-existent and cannot be stolen no more that I can steal someones vary thoughts right out of their head. This Intellectual Property is a fraud on is face.
  •  
  • Jo Jitty 3 years ago
    Finally! The MPAA proves it really is good for something! LOL

    RT
    privacy-web.net.tc
  •  
  • Adrian B plus 3 years ago
    How was everyone in the room not howling with laughter? Someone must have had a clue how preposterous this is.

    If educators have to worry about litigation for showing video clips then the entire foundation for copyright law as laid out in the constitution is in complete rubble.
  •  
  • Emrah Gunduz plus 3 years ago
    What a great way of thinking. Education ideas at its lowest moment...

    So, if you are a student of video arts, your teacher will not be able to show you clips from DVDs because it breaks DMCA.

    But it is OK to cam record and show it ? Crappy video and sound you get is not protected by copyright laws then ?...

    I still don't understand how MPAA got this much power over movie industry. There are too many constitutions that do nothing, yet control everything...
  •  
  • glop glop 3 years ago
    Somebody should tell the MPAA that we're in 2009, not in 1979 ...
  •  
  • korkas 3 years ago
    This is embarrassing not just for teachers, but for humanity. I'm in disbelief at the waste of time and money occurring in that room.
  •  
  • InsProductions 3 years ago
    omfg... they're crazy :S
  •  
  • Iglesias 3 years ago
    they want to kill evolution... but they can't!
  •  
  • Aitor F 3 years ago
    That was so retarded...
  •  
  • Dave Dugdale plus 3 years ago
    Wow, that is so wrong.
  •  
  • Joey Ferrara 3 years ago
    Omg I just...wanna laugh and cry at the same time!!! This is the most brilliant display of pure idiocy and irony. It just boggles my mind that their exist such brainless people out there! The irony is just crushing me!!! I just wanna..... GGGAHHHHHDJGIJHfgPKJH
  •  
  • Jason Jang 3 years ago
    MPAA,you've already lost the battle against piracy.Go f**k your selves before everyon turns into pirates,idiots.
  •  
  • Jens Krautscheid plus 4 months ago
    Brilliant! You wouldn't be able to script that for an episode of Seinfeld or BigBangTheory.
  •  
This conversation is missing your voice. Take five seconds to join Vimeo or log in.

Advertisement

About this video

MP4
00:04:18
  • 640x480, 21.49MB
  • Uploaded Wed May 06, 2009
  • Please join or log in to download
  • License:
4 Related collections

Statistics

Date Plays Comments
Totals 88.8K 48 38
Dec 17th 0 0 0
Dec 16th 3 0 0
Dec 15th 3 0 0
Dec 14th 5 0 0
Dec 13th 3 0 0
Dec 12th 2 0 0
Dec 11th 2 0 0

Related lessons from Vimeo Video School

Check out these lessons to learn more about how you can make videos like this one!