March 21, 2007
For Immediate Release
Apotex Invalidates Norvasc® Patent
Company to Launch In Near FutureWeston, FL (March 21, 2007) - Apotex Corp. announced today the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals in the case of Pfizer, Inc. v. Apotex, Inc. reversed a trial court's ruling and found that Pfizer's U.S. Patent 4,879,303 (the '303 patent) covering the Pfizer product Norvasc® was invalid. The '303 patent covers amlodipine besylate the active ingredient in Norvasc® as well as tablets made from amlodipine besylate. Because the limiting patent expires in two days, no company will have exclusivity over the product. Apotex expects to launch the product in the very near future.
The Federal Circuit found that Apotex had proven that the '303 patent was invalid because it was obvious. In other words, the patent should never had been issued because someone skilled in the art would have known to make amlodipine besylate from materials, called prior art, that were publicly available. The Federal Circuit cited as some of the prior art an earlier Pfizer patent that taught amlodipine maleate as well as amlodipine with other pharmaceutically acceptable salts. The earlier Pfizer patent did not specifically mention besylate but the Court found that it was sufficient that besylate salt was discussed in other pieces of prior art.
By finding the Pfizer '303 patent invalid and not infringed by Apotex's ANDA, the Court is allowing Apotex to obtain final approval for its generic amlodipine besylate product. By finding Pfizer'303 patent invalid the Court also causes Pfizer to loose the additional six months of pediatric exclusivity that they had obtained.
"Our pursuit of this case after losing at the District Court level was rooted in Apotex's belief that the right thing to do for consumers and customers is to never, ever stop fighting to bring generics to market at the earliest possible time," said Apotex CEO Barry Sherman. "There was no guarantee when we appealed the case that we would be able to enter the market if we won. The odds, in fact, were against us achieving that outcome. But we believed we have an obligation to consumers to keep fighting, and are extremely pleased that our victory in the courts will bring significant savings in short order to the US health care system."
"It goes without saying that we will continue to press on all fronts for changes in the US legislative and regulatory framework that will better serve consumers . The commitment to the consumer that guided our actions in this case will continue to guide our efforts in Washington, DC, for instance, to work with policymakers to put an end to anti-competitive patents settlements that delay consumer access to affordable, quality generic medicines," Sherman added.
"Today's decision also has implications for the outcome of the clopidogrel case as some of the same legal principles are at stake in that trial. As today's ruling underscores, consumers can be sure we will do everything in our power to prevail in that case as well," Sherman added.
The Apotex Group manufactures more than 200 different high-quality generic pharmaceuticals, used by millions of patients worldwide. Its product line includes oral solids, liquids, injectables, nasal sprays, opthalmics, and inhalation solutions.
Norvasc® is a registered trademark of Pfizer, Inc.
Apotex Corp. is the U.S. subsidiary of Apotex Inc., the largest Canadian-owned manufacturer of prescription drugs. Through its sales and marketing headquarters in Weston, Florida and operations center in Indianapolis, Apotex Corp. is committed to providing safe and affordable generic medicines. Products manufactured and marketed by the Apotex Group are sold in 115 countries around the world. For more information visit www.apotexcorp.com.