Discussion about this post

User's avatar
George Slade's avatar

So glad I found a receptive audience for Alfred's apples. Thanks Andy!

Expand full comment
søren k. harbel's avatar

Lovely apples. I have such a love hate relationship with Stieglitz. His arrogance and decisions around who was in the Camera Work club and who wasn't and how much manipulation wealthy amateurs had to do to be accepted as 'artists' by Stieglitz, was such a set-back to photography, I swear it took the art of photography at least 50 years to recover. Don't forget that in the late 1800s it was perfectly fine to have a straight photograph of the Acropolis hanging along side a Japanese woodblock print, along side a landscape painting. Stieglitz made that impossible. And for those photographers who actually had to work for a living... forget it. You had to be rich, and an amateur. Otherwise, you did not count. Yes, he sort of redeemed himself late in life, but he single-handedly set photography back decades!

As for the apples.... "a symbol—of Eve’s temptation in the Garden of Eden", come on, sometimes an apple is just an apple. A good photograph, just a good photograph.

Expand full comment
19 more comments...

No posts